Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

...For very young people there are also two universes. Squatting over a tub of warm water is a much cheaper and healthier way to give birth than lying on your back in a harsh hospital room where the high priest will take the infant away from the mother to teach it alienation...

Arghhh. Having children is _not easy_. There's a reason we still say "Mom and baby are healthy and happy." For a long time we lost one or both pretty regularly. I don't agree with all aspects of western society, but clean hospitals and infant intensive care units are most of the reason infant mortality has dropped.




I can't agree more with you on that point !

Just reading it made me cringe for the author. Infant mortality is inversely correlated with usage of scientific medicine and hygiene. Look at history.

Even now, we can inversely correlate any country infant mortality with its level of medical equipment.


Childbirth is not _easy_, but it's certainly a normal part of life, and treating it like a sickness, requiring hospitalization, is perverse.

We had the last 4 of our 8 at home, with, yes, one close call, but with a competent midwife, that's par for the course.


Childbirth isn't done in hospitals because it's a sickness, it's done in hospitals in case an emergency happens. I couldn't have been born at home--my mother would have to have been whisked away to a hospital for a c-section anyway. The fact that she was already in the hospital and attended to by an obstetrician made that process considerably safer and more reliable.


That's actually not true. Better doctor hygiene practices is most of the reason infant mortality has dropped.


I'm pretty sure that's what he meant by "clean hospitals".


but can be achieved in the home with a hygenic midwife and surroundings




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: