Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Analogous question: At what percentage of uses for crime should guns be banned?



false equivalence, guns kill people, piracy doesn’t


Analogous question: At what percentage of uses for crime should train ticket copy machines be banned?


i’m okay with them not being banned? i don’t really give a shit if municipalities and train companies lose money


The problem is that this breaks down very fast. You would eventually care, when those people can no longer operate and then you're affected, i.e. this is a problem of selfishness.

People pirating Nintendo games AND people playing Nintendo games DO care - when Nintendo no longer makes money and there's no more games to play. And I know they care, because they're playing and love the games right now. So it is their problem, regardless of what they say. Their very actions prove it's their problem.


You would give "a shit" if you relied on the train and the company closed down. Certainly the people that do, do.


i don’t, i use my car. no need for a train. until we have high speed rail on the level of japan across the continental US, i have no interest in seeing trains succeed


There is this thing called "ethics"...




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: