I think you missed my point slightly, sorry my explaining probably.
I mean timescale as in between two points in time. Between the two points it meets the intelligence criteria you mentioned.
Feeding human vetted GPT4 data into GPT5 is no different to a human receiving inputs from its interaction with the world and learning. More accurate means smarter, gradually it's intrinsic world model improves as does reasoning etc.
I agree those are the things that will advance it but taking a step back it potentially meets that criteria even if less useful day to day (given its an abstract viewpoint over time and not at the human level).
I mean timescale as in between two points in time. Between the two points it meets the intelligence criteria you mentioned. Feeding human vetted GPT4 data into GPT5 is no different to a human receiving inputs from its interaction with the world and learning. More accurate means smarter, gradually it's intrinsic world model improves as does reasoning etc.
I agree those are the things that will advance it but taking a step back it potentially meets that criteria even if less useful day to day (given its an abstract viewpoint over time and not at the human level).